Which version of Hu Jun, Huang Rihua and Hu Jun, is more classic?
This issue has been debated among martial arts fans.
Not long ago, fork fork found that the score of a certain petal of the 2003 version of "Tianlong Eight Parts" has risen to 8.5 points, and the gap between the 97 version of "Tianlong Eight Parts" with a score of 9.0 is gradually narrowing.
This means that more and more viewers are beginning to like the 2003 version of "Tianlong Babu".
Originally, I thought that huang rihua's version of Qiao Summit would have a high probability of beating Hu Jun's version of Qiao Feng, but in the comment area, there were many voices of "Hu Jun is better than Huang Rihua".
Even after 20 years, the question of who Is Qiao Feng authentic in huang Rihua and Hu Jun can still stir up a scolding war among netizens.
It should be known that Although Huang Rihua's version of "Tianlong Babu" is a lot of memories of the 80s and 90s, it obviously cannot be compared with the Hu Jun version with abundant investment and all-star luxury lineup.
It is unfair to compare two TV series with a difference of 6 years and an investment difference of dozens of times.
The following fork fork will carefully analyze Huang Rihua and Hu Jun from the three aspects of appearance, acting skills, action design, etc., who is the best Qiao Feng:
shape
According to the official data, Huang Rihua's height is only 1.75 meters.
If you put them in these post-60s Hong Kong actors, their height is not low. You should know that Zhou Runfa, who is less than one meter and eight meters tall, can be described as standing out from the crowd.
But actors are certainly hydrated when they declare their height outwards.
Taking Huang Rihua's other masterpiece "The Legend of the Archery Hero" as an example, there is not much gap between him and Weng Meiling, who is 1.59 meters tall.
The difference between the two is about 10 centimeters, throwing shoes and other heightened clothing, Huang Rihua's height is about 1.71 to 1.73 meters.
In the group photo of the three people of Virtual Bamboo and Duan Yu, with the visual common sense of "near big and far small", Huang Rihua's version of Qiao Feng is closer to the camera, but it is no taller than the two people behind him.
In order to make up for the lack of height and the thinness of the figure, when filming "Tianlong Babu", the crew also specially designed a hat and beard for Huang Rihua to increase height and create the exotic characteristics of Qiao Feng Khitan.
Fortunately, Huang Rihua's acting skills are outstanding, and he covers many characteristics of his Cantonese with his torch-like eyes and resolute face.
However, the innate body disadvantage does not fit the role setting of Qiao Feng's northern han.
As a northern Hanzi, Hu Jun's height reached a staggering 1.85 meters.
From the same frame shots of Lin Zhiying, Liu Tao, Chen Hao and other actors, the audience can clearly feel the sense of oppression brought by Hu Jun's figure.
Here Fork fork quotes the description of Qiao Feng in the original novel:
Duan Yu saw that this person was of great stature, more than thirty years old, wearing an old gray cloth robe, slightly tattered, thick eyebrows, big eyes, high nose and wide mouth, a four-square Chinese character face, quite the color of wind and frost, and when he looked forward to it, he was extremely powerful.
It can be said that Hu Jun extremely restored the rough appearance of Qiao Feng's northern Hanzi in the original work.
Even the original author, Jin Yong, praised Qiao Feng, played by Hu Jun, saying that he performed the appearance of Qiao Feng in his heart.
Of course, it is not that Hu Jun's version completely crushed Huang Rihua, due to the producer Zhang Jizhong's overzealous penchant for hair dryers to create a flowing effect, Qiao Feng, played by Hu Jun, has always maintained a state of cape distribution.
The temperament of the whole person is more inclined to the mountain bandits, and lacks a little of the calmness of the hero. Appear fierce and chivalrous.
But in any case, Hu Jun's version of Qiao Feng is closer to the original work than Huang Rihua in terms of aura and image.
Winner of this round: Hu Jun
acting
Thanks to years of acting experience, Huang Rihua can not only interpret Guo Jing's honest attitude, but also portray Qiao Feng's righteous thin cloud sky into three points.
Huang Rihua made up for his height disadvantage with his firm eyes and domineering aura, which is enough to show that his acting skills have reached the superb point of changing his life against the sky.
It is worth mentioning that Huang Rihua once played a virtual bamboo in the 82nd version of "Tianlong Eight Parts", and interpreted the virtual bamboo honestly to the fullest, far higher than the later Fan Shaohuang and Gao Hu.
It is no wonder that the reputation of being known as the "first male protagonist of Jin Yong" is well deserved.
Although as early as 2001, he won many awards such as the Golden Horse Award and the Chinese Media Award for "Lan Yu", Hu Jun, who was added to the film emperor, won the TV Golden Eagle Award with "Tianlong Babu", which shows that his acting skills have been recognized by the public.
However, limited by the disadvantage of Hu Jun's small eyes, the inner drama of many complex emotions is not delicate enough.
There is no basis for saying that there is no basis for saying that Qiao Feng knows his identity as a Khitan.
When Huang Rihua learned of his Khitan origins, he was first incredulous, then shocked, questioning Master Zhiguang in a skeptical tone, the emotions were progressive, and the collapse of faith had no performance traces, more like the reaction of a normal person.
After Hu Jun's version of Qiao Feng learned of his own life from Master Zhiguang, he instead showed a bloodthirsty fierce god of evil, as if he wanted to expose the bad things that killed everyone present.
Winner of the round: Huang Rihua
Motion design
As a Hong Kong TV drama that has always been known for its martial arts moves, most artists will undergo martial arts routine training in the training class.
As an actor in the 9th session of the Wireless Art Training Class, Huang Rihua is no exception.
In 1982, AT TVB's Taiqing, Huang Rihua performed acrobatics with The Wireless Five Tigers composed of Andy Lau and others, and his one-man show of fast dancing and double knife showed that the basic martial arts foundation was still relatively convincing.
However, due to the fact that Hong Kong dramas in the late 1990s began to rely too much on special effects, the "Eighteen Palms of the Descending Dragon" played by Huang Rihua's version had more mysterious meanings.
Although most of the actors are mainland actors, Zhang Jizhong specially invited Yuan Bin and Zhao Jian, two famous celebrities in the martial arts circle.
Coupled with the fact that the exploration of domestic special effects has begun to bear fruit, the entire move of "Descending Dragon Eighteen Palms" is more courageous, and the sound effect of the tiger roaring dragon chant has increased the domineering degree of the move.
Also taking the Juxian Zhuang War as an example, the Huang Rihua version is still in the process of seeing moves and dismantling moves, and occasionally the eighteen palms of the descending dragon are blessed, and the sense of elegance is full.
And the Hu Jun version is simply a crushing battle, and the move of descending the eighteen palms of the dragon makes Qiao Feng look like a killing god, full of deterrence.
No matter from which aspect, Hu Jun's version amplifies the characteristics of Qiao Feng's moves and highlights the character.
Winner of this round: Hu Jun
Other versions of Joe Peak
In addition to Huang Rihua's version and Hu Jun's version of "Tianlong Babu", the 2013 version starring Zhong Hanliang and the 2021 version starring Yang Youning were nailed to the column of shame because of various magic changes and the actor's disgusting acting skills.
For example, in the 2013 version, Zhong Hanliang was actually labeled with a "flashy" hat with the appearance of a skateboard, and it is difficult for the audience to associate the idol drama spokesperson with the gas cover cloud sky.
Coupled with Duan Yu's direct use of Korean actor Kim Ki-fan, a domestic martial arts story had to find foreigners to perform, which made the play be criticized.
After the premiere of Mango SATELLITE TV aired more than a dozen episodes, it was hurriedly dropped, which is the biggest joke in the TV drama industry in 2013.
As the latest version of "Tianlong Eight Parts", Yang Youning's version of Qiao Feng is also not optimistic.
Yang Youning was not suitable for ancient costumes, and the stylist referred to the modeling in Hu Jun's version of "Tianlong Babu", but unfortunately, Yang Youning's cape-emitting appearance did not perform, and the greasy feeling overflowed the screen.
If it is most forgotten by the audience, it is also the first time it has been put on the screen, it should be the 1982 version of "Tianlong Babu".
Liang Jiaren, who had not yet become a "Wu Zhuangyuan" at that time, played the hero Qiao Feng, and he took into account the chivalrous tenderness of Huang Rihua's version and the rough temperament of Hu Jun's version. It can be said that the temperament shape is closest to the original Qiao Feng.
Tang Zhenye's Duan Yu, Huang Rihua's virtual bamboo, and Duan Zhengchun, played by Xie Xian, definitely made this drama a star at that time.
Murong Fu, played by Shi Xiu, is a person who has never come after the ancients, and at the end of the TV series, Murong Bo killed the sweeping priest and became the final big BOSS, which changed the drawbacks of the original novel without a major play, and improved the entertainment of the story.
Whether it is Huang Rihua's "chivalrous" Qiao Feng or Hu Jun's "tall" Qiao Feng, they all selected the right people at the right time and became a generation of divine dramas that affected the audience.
In contrast, the protagonists of today's martial arts films only care about blindly posing, and the action scenes are even more like dancing, without good scripts and martial fingers, so that today's martial arts films have completely become costume idol dramas that talk about love.
Perhaps in a few decades, whether it is the Huang Rihua version or the Hu Jun version, it can still be enjoyed by the audience, and the audience has its own understanding of Qiao Feng.
Having said all that, which version of Qiao Feng do you think is the most classic?
This article is the original of the fork to see the film, without my permission may not be reproduced plagiarism, violators will be investigated.