Text: Muzi
Editor|Zhouzhou Film and Television Entertainment Review
The much-anticipated "Singer 2024" has finally come to an end.
However, instead of flowers and applause, it was insulting and questioning.
Singer Zhen Ni even directly posted a post questioning the program team and Na Ying's identity as the king of singers.
This also reminds people of what Tian Zhen said on the show 23 years ago.
1, the controversial singer
Na Ying, who has only won the first place in the regular season once, really bottomed out in the final and won the championship.
For a while, the question of whether Na Ying is worthy or not has once again aroused heated discussions.
In addition to the controversy of netizens, the eldest sister in the music world, Da Zhenni, also directly fired at the "Singer" program group.
questioned that the program team should not play if they couldn't afford it, called foreigners over, and finally deliberately targeted foreign players.
Na Ying, who has a vested interest, also accidentally lay down and was bombarded by Zhenni.
Zhen Ni has always been known for her straightforwardness in the entertainment industry, and this speech also expressed the voices of netizens.
Many netizens concluded: The first phase of foreigners taught domestic entertainment singing, and the last phase taught foreigners to be people.
It's simply the words "relying on relationships to go through the back door" on the face of the program team.
Many netizens also began to analyze the last episode of the singer's program frame by frame.
found that except for the program team who firmly awarded the title of singer to Na Ying, many other people were very unpopular.
2, Di Mahi and Liu Huan are not on the show?
The reason why Na Ying was the first to cause controversy was in addition to questioning Na Ying's own strength.
It is important to note that Canada singer Fancia, who is considered the most likely to win the championship, unexpectedly fell out of the top three.
Facing the fourth place, the gang singer Dimashi from Kazakhstan also stepped forward to comfort.
It's just that Di Mahi didn't seem to turn off the microphone when he said this, and it was clearly captured by the camera lens.
“They said it must be Chinese singer before you”（他们说中国人一定要在你前面）。
Di Mahi participated in the program of "Singer 2017" a long time ago, and rushed all the way to the final from the starter.
In the end, he was ranked second in the year.
This time, Di Mahi was invited to help sing United States black singer Shantimo, and he is also familiar with the competition system of "Singer".
After Zhang Jie, who was present, heard this, he also hurriedly pulled Di Mahi away, in case he said anything else.
But the TV broadcast has gone out, and there is an English listening god who analyzes Dimahi's complete sentences through lip syncing and context.
“Before you on the stage, I want to tell you something about, when they invited me to sing, they said must be a Chinese before you.”
(Before you go on stage, I want to tell you one thing, when they invited me to sing, they said there must be Chinese in front of you.) ）
Later, Di Mahi also made a clarification, saying that he did not mean that there must be Chinese in front of Fanxia.
Instead, he said that he wanted to star on the same stage as Fanxia, but the program team said that a Chinese must partner with Fanxia.
In this way, it can only be said that Di Mahi's refutation of rumors has become an invalid refutation of rumors, but it has confirmed that the program team interfered with foreign singers' song selection.
Long before the start of the competition, there was news that Fancia's two favorite songs were killed.
Because the song selection was killed, Van Xiya finally changed to this song that was not suitable for competition.
Forcibly pairing Di Mahi with Shantimo actually greatly affected Shantimo's play.
Although at first glance, both of them are singing high notes, together they should complement each other.
But Dimahi's dolphin sound is actually different from Shantimo's whistle.
It's hard to match together, either they just sing their own songs, or someone has to make a trade-off and give up their strengths.
Originally, these rumors made the program team controversial, and now Di Mahi has confirmed the rumors, which has made the program team deeply involved in public opinion.
In addition to foreign singers questioning the fairness of the show, domestic singers are also not optimistic about this result.
In addition to Zhen Ni's public bombardment of the program team, Liu Huan on the show also "voted with his feet", expressing his resistance to Na Ying's victory.
At the moment when it was announced that Na Ying had won the championship, Liu Huan left the camera directly, as if he didn't want to take a photo of Na Ying.
Even Na Ying was very embarrassed at that moment, wondering if this result would definitely cause an uproar on the Internet.
However, compared with discussing shady scenes, netizens are more curious, what is Na Ying's performance in this issue?
3, how did Na Ying perform
In the stage of three into one, "Flowers" sung by Na Ying and Rejuvenation Dan together is actually quite good.
As Ding Taisheng said, although the combination of Chantimo and Di Mahi is very good, it is not ornamental enough.
Shantimo's rhythm is good, and he can see the skills, but the overall effect is not good, which is still realistic.
And Wang Sulong and Gu Juji's singing is even more disastrous, it can be said that there is nothing to want.
A song that is not suitable for competition is sung by two singers who are not suitable for competition without a match, and it is naturally difficult to compare.
And the song "Flowers" is very suitable for competition, which has been tested by "Summer of the Band".
Although Na Ying's last sensational speech split the whole song into two paragraphs, the overall effect was weakened.
But it is undeniable that variety shows are very sensational.
At this point, Na Ying really understands variety shows very well.
So there is no doubt that Na Ying can advance to the finals.
The most critical question is whether Na Ying can win the king of singers.
According to Ding Taisheng's conclusion, Na Ying can completely win the king of singers, after all, the performance of several other players is not very good.
The song chosen by the favorite Fancia is indeed not a suitable song for competition.
She uses the Arabic transliteration, which she is very good at.
This is also the characteristic singing method of Fanxia's hometown Morocco, and Fanxia's completion is very high.
But in a few high-pitched works, such a bland song is easily forgotten by the audience.
In addition, it is a foreign language, so it is naturally difficult to impress the subconscious of the judges.
Tan Weiwei and Sun Nan's singing impact on the singer is also a bit laborious, and even gives people a feeling of "letting" the singer.
Ding Taisheng's use of the word "let" to describe this year's battle of singers is very ingenious.
Because only Na Ying's song selection is here for the competition.
Na Ying chose a song by Wang Feng "Free Like a Dream", which is indeed very suitable for competition.
It is possible that the program team did not manipulate the results of the ballot.
But with this huge difference in song selection, it's hard not to make people think about it.
Tan Weiwei and Sun Nan still showed their personal style, and Fan Xiya really "let" too much.
This is not the first time that Na Ying won the championship, as early as 23 years ago, Tian Zhen broke with Na Ying because of this.
4, Tian Zhen: It's okay if you don't get it
Tian Zhen entered the music scene earlier than Na Ying, but today, Tian Zhen is obviously inferior to Na Ying in terms of popularity.
A large part of the reason for this is because Tian Zhen once publicly tore apart the program team and Na Ying on the podium.
The two were originally peaceful and sang their own songs, but in 2001, an award linked the two together.
At that time, Tian Zhen was voted by the audience and was selected as the "most popular female singer".
But when the award was presented, it was Na Ying's name that was finally announced.
If it were an ordinary person, it was likely that he would swallow his anger at this time and suffer a dumb loss.
But Tian Zhen didn't, she strode onto the podium and took the microphone.
Seeing Tian Zhen taking the microphone, the program team also hurriedly closed the microphone in case Tian Zhen said anything discordant.
Tian Zhen saw that there was no sound in the microphone, so he questioned the program team on stage:
If this award is fair, can you please turn on the microphone?
Tian Zhen's eloquent words ushered in an enthusiastic response from the fans in the audience.
Since Tian Zhen didn't win the award, who won the award in the end?
is the second best voted by fans.
After this incident, Na Ying and Tian Zhen's beam was also concluded.
Tian Zhen didn't give the host face at all, and left a sentence:
If I have a great deal of doubt about this award, I don't have to accept it.
Then he left the scene angrily, leaving behind cheering fans, and the extremely embarrassed program team and Na Ying.
In order to reverse the word of mouth, the program team later came up with a "Global Chinese Most Popular Singer Award" and decided to award it to Tian Zhen.
In the end, he was ridiculed by Tian Zhen and refused to accept this "undeserved" award.
It can be seen that the doubts of fans and friends about the results of "Singer 2024" are not groundless.
It is a response to the bad atmosphere in the music industry that has accumulated over time.
5. Programs that are gradually losing credibility
According to musicians such as Ding Taisheng, it is understandable that Na Ying took the king of singers.
Why can't a voted singer convince the public?
In the final analysis, it is because the credibility of the program team has fallen to the bottom.
At the beginning of "Singer 2024", people speculated that the program group had a shady scene, and in the end it must be Na Ying's champion.
For foreign players, some of the practices of the program team did hinder their performance.
For example, arranging inappropriate guest singers, asking for a change of song, etc., all of which have an impact on the final result of the competition.
If a competitive music program can't be open and transparent enough to convince most people.
A single notary public certification will not do anything, because all the judges are selected.
No matter how good you usually behave, you can be eliminated through some possible shady scenes in the end.
In the next program, if the program team can't really be open and transparent.
Then the competitive programs can no longer be held, and the award ceremony can be held directly.
If the competition is not about technology, but about human sophistication, then what is the difference between it and pulling people to vote?
The eyes of the masses are bright, and the uncrowned king with the reputation of the masses is far greater than the so-called champion who is not worthy of the name.
epilogue
Music itself is subject to individual aesthetic differences.
So it's hard for us to say whether the program team has behind-the-scenes operations.
But when a show can't guarantee even the most basic fairness and can't convince the audience.
This also means that the credibility of the program team has fallen to the bottom.
Some references:
"Singer 2024" Mango TV
Na Ying won the championship of "Singer 2024" and burst into tears on the stage: I really didn't expect it!