Unclear determination of facts provides the soil for the existence of injustice, and procedural violations are the biggest enemy of fairness, law enforcers directly undermine the law of fairness, and even use the power in their hands to overwhelm the law, the resulting unfairness is terrible, who else can the people believe?
What is the purpose of the program's existence? This is a rule established by the country to ensure social fairness and justice, and everyone must abide by it unconditionally.
Relying on the rule of man, people will have feelings, and it is difficult to ensure fairness if there are feelings; Relying on rules, rules are dead, fairness can be guaranteed, "no rules are not a circle", this is the meaning of the existence of rules.
The purpose of "procedural illegality" is to circumvent the law in order to achieve the purpose of evading the law, how can this kind of behavior safeguard the rules of the country? How can fairness and justice be guaranteed?
A few days ago, lawyer Ji posted a work, a case represented by Ji Lu was remanded for retrial because of "unclear determination of facts and illegal procedures", this is the second time that it has been remanded for retrial, the reason is very amazing, why did the local court not even determine the basic facts of the case clearly? How can we ensure fairness and justice if we dare to make a judgment if the facts are not clear?
The most appalling thing is that there are still "procedural violations" in the cases represented by lawyer Ji, which is a typical behavior that breaks the rules, and it is impossible to have a fair and just conclusion about procedural violations. Why do they dare to break the law? If it weren't for the existence of the rules of the family and the country, would the unjust, false and wrong be formed?
If it weren't for the fact that they wanted to circumvent the rules of procedure, would these people be guilty of "procedural violations"? It can be seen that sometimes it is difficult for the procedure to restrain the behavior of some people, especially the selfish behavior, they use the power in their hands to wantonly break the rules, so the conclusion drawn is also called "official announcement", and the conclusion of "official announcement" must be accepted?
Of course, the verdict conclusion of "the facts are unclear and the procedure is illegal" will not be accepted by the world, not all "official announcements" must be accepted, questioning "official announcements" is not questioning the rules of the family and country, questioning the "official announcements" is precisely to maintain the rules of the family and the country from being broken by anyone, even if you are a judge in a robe, which is why netizens can question the "official announcement" of "wrong life".
Did the "wrong life" incident clearly identify the facts? In which link were Yao Ce and Guo Wei replaced?
A case that has been ascertained is a prerequisite for ensuring that it is treated fairly, and without a clear determination of the facts, how can fairness and justice begin?
Is Du Mouzhi Yao Ce born in Huaihe Hospital? This is a very basic question, if it cannot be proved that Du Mouzhi gave birth to a child in Huaihe Hospital, how can Huaihe Hospital start to talk about infringement?
The only evidence we can see now to prove that Du Mouzhi was born in Huaihe Hospital is the medical record provided by Huaihe Hospital, which has been questioned by the world as a forgery, and can a medical record that has been altered in more than 200 places be used as evidence? If this kind of altered medical record is not identified, it will certainly not be regarded as valid evidence, and Kaifeng's consistent refusal to evaluate medical records is also very puzzling.
Is the refusal and non-evaluation of medical records a procedural irregularity? It may also be an illegal act, Uncle Gulou does not identify the altered medical records, the hammer of the building refuses to identify the altered medical records, your behavior makes the altered medical records lie in the medical record room forever, but how do you prove that Du Mouzhi gave birth to a child in Huaihe Hospital?
There are many ways to prove that Du Mouzhi gave birth to a child in Huaihe Hospital, such as Du Mouzhi providing a medical birth certificate from Huaihe Hospital, Kaifeng Wei Committee providing a record of Du Mouzhi's medical birth certificate, or the hospital providing Du Mouzhi's birth certificate attachment, or the household registration department can provide Du Mouzhi's medical birth certificate, but none of these are available.
If Huaihe Hospital can provide Du Mouzhi's payment list in the hospital and can also prove that Du Mouzhi was born in Huaihe Hospital, this payment form can be mutually corroborated with Du Mouzhi's medical records, and the hospital's payment form can be kept for a long time, Ms. Xu can make a copy, and Ms. Du should of course also make a copy, why not provide these evidence?
There is no evidence to prove that Du Mouzhi was born in Huaihe Hospital, Yao Ce, and all the subsequent infringement compensation has no basis, and such an important fact has not been clearly determined, so what kind of lawsuit is there to fight?
Were Yao Ce and Guo Wei swapped in the shower? What is the basis for the interpretation of the sketch in Kaifeng? A performance that is not supported by facts is just a performance, and such a deduction is not reasoning.
Yao Ce and Guo Wei were not born on the same day, and Yao Ce was still the child of a woman with hepatitis B, so what was the obstetric management system of Huaihe Hospital at that time? Can the testimony of the medical staff of Huaihe Hospital in the 918 court and the sketch of Uncle Gulou corroborate each other?
The sketch interpretation of the drum tower, first, did not confirm that the two children may have intersected when taking a bath, and second, did not take a bath in accordance with the rules of the obstetrics department of Huaihe Hospital, how can such a sketch interpretation convince the public?
The altered medical records cannot be regarded as facts, and there must be a factual basis for the presumption that Du Mouzhi gave birth to a child in Huaihe Hospital, and the two children were replaced in Huaihe Hospital cannot be reversed Du Mouzhi gave birth to a child in Huaihe Hospital, how did Du Mouzhi's child get to the hospital There are many possibilities, and how to prove that Yao Ce must have been born in Huaihe Hospital?
Is Kaifeng's determination that Ms. Du gave birth in Huaihe Hospital in accordance with the procedures? There is no clear factual basis for such a rash determination in violation of procedural provisions.
Uncle Gulou's determination that there is "management chaos" in Huaihe Hospital is a typical violation of procedures, and "management chaos" has a strong professionalism, and Drum Tower does not have this professional condition, so of course they cannot directly determine that the hospital has "management chaos", and whether there is "management chaos" in Huaihe Hospital should be handed over to the professional department to determine, and the identification of Drum Tower is not effective.
Uncle Gulou did not identify the medical records, and there were flaws in the procedure, so why did the Loulou Courtyard also insist on not appraising the medical records? With the endorsement of Uncle Gulou's conclusion, is Loulou Yuan procedurally legal?
Ms. Xu's claim did not say "secretly exchanged", however, the Loulouyuan Court violated the procedure and went beyond the litigation request to talk about whether there was a "secret exchange" in the "wrong life" incident, and whether there was a criminal claim, and whether there was a criminal claim to talk about this issue, but there was no criminal investigation at all, but the Loulouyuan Court talked about the absence of "secretly exchange" in the judgment.
The judgment has determined that Ms. Xu's child was "illegally removed from guardianship", what is the basis for this determination? Since it is determined that the child was "illegally removed from guardianship", it is necessary to find out the person who committed the "illegal" act, so that Guo Wei "illegally escaped from guardianship", isn't it an illegal act? But why doesn't the verdict reflect this?
Ms. Du sued Huaihe Hospital for infringement, why did she use Ms. Xu's child's birth certificate? If this situation is reasonable, should Ms. Xu sue Huaihe Hospital take Ms. Du's child's birth certificate? In other words, Ms. Xu's child's birth certificate is used for two purposes, which proves that Ms. Du's child was born in Huaihe Hospital, and at the same time, it also proves that Ms. Xu's child was born in Huaihe Hospital.
Ms. Du and Yao Ce sued Huaihe Hospital for infringement, why did they bring Guo Wei's 91 households to court? Who asked for cross-examination of Guo Wei's 91 households? What is the purpose of cross-examining these 91 households? Guo Wei is not the subject of the lawsuit, why should he cross-examine his 91 households? Moreover, did the building courtyard figure out Guo Wei's 91 households? I don't know what to cross-examine in court?
There has been an "official announcement" on the "wrong life" incident, but has the Drum Tower Courtyard clearly identified the facts? This matter has gone through several court hearings, but none of them have found out the truth, and there are procedural irregularities? If the procedures are fully compliant and legal, will there be no truth to the "wrong life" incident?