It is said that those who read my articles have become big bosses, please use your golden finger to make a fortune, pay attention to the top and like it, it is difficult to do it if you don't want to get rich Like and walk, love you to permanently, focus on a little, get rich to permanent, I wish you good luck in spring, summer, autumn and winter, and meet nobles in the southeast and northwest
"Dream of Red Mansions", a classic masterpiece with a pivotal position in the history of Chinese literature, not only has great weight on the screen, but also vividly depicts vivid characters with magnificent waves and intricate plots, which deeply attracts the attention of the audience.
Wang Xifeng is undoubtedly the most striking of the many plump and vivid characters. She is passionate, good-looking, resolute, intelligent, and has a unique personality that makes her the center of attention.
The appearance characteristics of "triangular eyes" and "willow eyebrows", coupled with the body shape of "slender and coquettish", make the vivid portrayal of her in the original book seem to be right in front of you.
Because of this, whenever a new version of "Dream of Red Mansions" comes out, who plays Wang Xifeng who can best interpret the character characteristics of the characters will arouse heated discussions among the audience. Wang Xifeng, a classic character, is vivid and three-dimensional, and her portrayal requires excellent acting skills and impeccable performances to make her shine on the screen.
In this controversy, Wang Xifeng, played by Liu Xiaoqing and Deng Jie in the 87 and 89 versions of "Dream of Red Mansions", is the focus of attention. Liu Xiaoqing was a well-known actress, and Deng Jie was a popular little flower at that time.
Although they have both played the role of Wang Xifeng, there are still major differences in how they portray their roles.
Wang Xifeng, played by Liu Xiaoqing, is full of vitality, spicy and domineering, fully showing the distinctive external characteristics of this "phoenix spicy". Her eyes, tone and demeanor all exuded Wang Xifeng's domineering aura, which was unforgettable.
It can be said that this work vividly shows Wang Xifeng's external strength.
In contrast, Deng Jie started more from the heart, and she successfully showed Wang Xifeng's rich versatility. From her sometimes confident and sometimes melancholy eyes, from her beauty and elegance when she dresses up, and from her sleek sophistication when dealing with others, we can see Deng Jie's in-depth understanding and complete presentation of the inner world of this complex character.
The image of Wang Xifeng created by her is so vivid and vivid that she seems to be able to breathe vividly in front of her eyes.
The two different acting styles made the audience discuss enthusiastically, Liu Xiaoqing's Wang Xifeng has a strong and decisive personality, but this also makes the character seem too thin; In contrast, Deng Jie's version of the character is interpreted in more detail, full of softness and resilience.
Which version is closer to the original and which actor's interpretation is more memorable, this has sparked discussions.
Indeed, there are obvious stylistic differences between Liu Xiaoqing and Deng Jie when creating the role of Wang Xifeng. Liu Xiaoqing's portrayal of Wang Xifeng is more overtly strong and domineering, while Deng Jie focuses on delicately portraying his inner world.
Liu Xiaoqing's neat tone, arrogant demeanor, and fierce eyes vividly interpreted Wang Xifeng's wild and uninhibited temperament. She was dressed in silk and satin, complacent, and her clothes were fluttering, like a pungent "phoenix spicy".
Liu Xiaoqing used her scolding and aggressive appearance to show Wang Xifeng's majestic and intimidating temperament to the fullest.
However, perhaps because she pays too much attention to external performance, her interpretation seems a little too stiff and thin. In contrast, Deng Jie's portrayal of Wang Xifeng's character is more rich and diverse, full of flexibility and human details, showing her deep-rooted acting skills.
She shows a wealth of emotional layers in her performance, sometimes grief-stricken, sometimes reserved and reserved, and sometimes she can be family-oriented, telling the story eloquently, making people fully feel the complexity and depth of Wang Xifeng's character.
When Deng Jie played Wang Xifeng, through her body language, eyes, expressions and manners, she appropriately showed Wang Xifeng's character traits of being soft on the outside and strong on the inside, proud and conceited.
Her hair is delicately combed, and she wears an embroidered silk dress, showing the elegance and nobility of everyone's ladies; However, she can talk eloquently and endlessly, like the best storyteller in the capital.
It is under this kind of fine control that Deng Jie's version of Wang Xifeng presents a more three-dimensional and closer image to the original work. She gives new life to this character, so that the audience no longer sees a single strong image, but a real woman with flesh and blood, alive and vivid.
The huge difference in the style of the two men led to a long-term debate over who was better in later generations. Liu Xiaoqing's version, while intriguing, is bland because it is too blunt and monolithic; On the contrary, Deng Jie used excellent detail control and profound inner analysis to make her Wang Xifeng's image shine.
The shining point of Wang Xifeng played by Deng Jie lies in her superb acting skills and deep understanding of the role.
Deng Jie portrayed Wang Xifeng, a complex character with a changeable personality and a tangled heart, very well. Sometimes she shows majesty and arrogance, sometimes she shows gentleness and virtuousness, and her expression and demeanor are very suitable for the character characteristics of "Feng Lazi".
She always maintains a dignified and generous attitude in the face of the wives, but she is spicy and wild in the face of the maids, showing Wang Xifeng's unexpected multifaceted nature all the time.
Deng Jie can convey the tenacity and tenderness in Wang Xifeng's heart through her eyes; Her words and deeds also reveal the unique personality of everyone's beautiful and soft on the outside, strong on the inside, and proud and conceited.
Under careful tasting, Deng Jie's control of this role can be described as extremely accurate and deserved.
In terms of styling, Deng Jie can be said to have put a lot of effort into it. She wears delicate hair accessories and gorgeous satin, showing Wang Xifeng's extraordinarily luxurious and beautiful temperament. Her movements are elegant and smooth, her eyes are like torches, and her smile shows the majesty of her master.
A closer look at the makeup on her face reveals that she is playful and handsome. She is like a smart girl like a small jasper, so beautiful that it makes people's hearts move.
Deng Jie's superb acting skills and well-crafted makeup successfully reproduced Wang Xifeng's image vividly in front of the audience, making people seem to be able to see a living Wang Xifeng walking, talking, and gasping in front of him.
She is both majestic and awe-inspiring, lively and delicate and cute, showing her dual characteristics everywhere, that is, the gentle and virtuous lady and the spicy and straightforward "Feng Lazi".
In addition to superb acting skills and appropriate makeup and styling, another highlight of Deng Jie's version of Wang Xifeng is the excellent soundtrack and sound effect settings. Compared with the monotonous and boring background sound of the 87 version, the crew of the 89 version pays more attention to restoring the rich changes in Wang Xifeng's inner world.
Deng Jie's outstanding acting talent and the changes in sound effects together create Wang Xifeng's vivid female image vividly, either brisk and lively, or low and melancholy, and the changes in sound effects all echo Wang Xifeng's state of mind.
The audience was amazed by the sight of him.
On the whole, Deng Jie's version of Wang Xifeng is warmly sought after by the audience, because of her superb acting skills, appropriate styling, and excellent soundtrack, which make this character vivid and three-dimensional, and it has become a classic that is difficult to surpass.
Liu Xiaoqing's version of Wang Xifeng's performance in many aspects does have some unavoidable shortcomings and deficiencies compared with Deng Jie's version.
First of all, some questions about styling and makeup. Although Liu Xiaoqing's coat jewelry, it always feels too simple and simple.
Her hairstyle is too simple, lacking the elegant atmosphere of aristocratic temperament; Although the clothes are luxurious, they cannot hide her simplicity. The overall shape does not show the elegance and arrogance of Wang Xifeng's unique style.
Moreover, Liu Xiaoqing seems to be a little stiff and contrived when using expressions and body language. Her facial expression is too stiff, and she rarely shows Wang Xifeng's melancholy and exaggerated rich inner world.
Most of her lines stay on the surface, and rarely dig deep into the inner struggles and contradictions of this character.
Compared with Deng Jie, Wang Xifeng's subtleties in personality were vividly captured by her. Not only can she capture the emotional fluctuations of this character anytime and anywhere, but she can also show it on the screen with superb acting skills.
In addition to the individual performances of the actors, the 87 version of the series still has a lot of room for improvement in terms of soundtrack and picture creation. In many cases, only some monotonous background sound effects are used as a supplement, and there is a serious lack of tension and drama that echoes the inner world of the characters.
At the same time, because the shooting technique at that time was too simple, it was difficult to handle every detail very well like Deng Jie's version.
The shortcomings of Liu Xiaoqing's version of Wang Xifeng are partly due to the actor's lack of personal understanding and expressiveness, and the other part is related to the limited production level and conditions of the year.
Liu Xiaoqing is a powerful actor, and her performance is a little incompetent when interpreting the special role of Wang Xifeng, but it cannot be denied that she has also had very wonderful performances in the portrayal of other roles.
In contrast, Deng Jie's version of Wang Xifeng shows a very high production level, whether it is the actor's personal performance or the later detail polishing, it has reached a very excellent realm, which makes people full of praise.
This is not a complete negation of Liu Xiaoqing's version, because each version has its own unique highlights. However, in the role of Wang Xifeng, Deng Jie did perform better.
In the ongoing debate about "who is the best Wang Xifeng", Liu Xiaoqing and Deng Jie are undoubtedly the two main points of contention. They all showed excellent acting skills in portraying this complex female character.
However, there is some disagreement about which of them performs better.
From the actor's personal point of view, Liu Xiaoqing is indeed a powerful actor, she has her own uniqueness in line control and emotional expression, especially in shaping other roles, she has reached a superb level.
However, for the specific role of Wang Xifeng, it seems that there is a certain deviation in his understanding and play.
Although she vividly showed Wang Xifeng's pungent and debauched, majestic and domineering side, she did not portray much of Wang Xifeng's delicate and fragile, melancholy and amorous heart.
Her performance is too thin and stiff, lacking depth and three-dimensionality.
In comparison, Wang Xifeng played by Deng Jie looks more plump and three-dimensional. She successfully interpreted the image of this clever, cunning, conceited and arrogant noble hostess, and at the same time did not ignore Wang Xifeng's deep tenderness and struggle.
Deng Jie's acting skills are superb enough to capture and show Wang Xifeng's ever-changing emotions at any time, and she can accurately interpret the uniqueness of the role of "Feng Lazi" through subtle expressions and demeanors, which is breathtaking.
In addition to the actors' individual performances, the entire crew also gave great support to Deng Jie's version in terms of production. Elaborate makeup and intense soundtrack sound effects add a lot to her performance.
The audience's eyes couldn't take their eyes off her, and it felt like Wang Xifeng, who was alive and flesh-and-blood, in front of them.
Compared with the 87 version, the TV series starring Liu Xiaoqing may be a little clumsy and jerky in terms of detail control and post-production. Although Liu Xiaoqing's personal acting skills are undoubted, it is a pity that the impression of the whole drama is still slightly inferior.
Due to the technical limitations of the time, it was very difficult to sketch the characters so delicately and so three-dimensionally and fully like the later ones.
Overall, Deng Jie's version of Wang Xifeng is slightly better in terms of the actor's personal performance and the blessing of the entire crew. She successfully showed the essence of the "Sister Feng" in the original book on the screen without reservation, which can be called a classic among the classics.
Although there is some controversy in Liu Xiaoqing's version of Wang Xifeng, its achievements cannot be completely denied because of this. Each version has its own highlights, and Liu Xiaoqing is also a powerful and excellent actor.
It's just that when interpreting the role of Wang Xifeng, she may need to improve her acting skills.
Deng Jie's version of "Dream of Red Mansions" is closer to the original and more emotionally infectious, while Liu Xiaoqing's version also has highlights, but the overall is relatively bland.
The purpose of this article is to advocate positive social energy, without vulgarity and other bad guidance. If you are involved in copyright or character infringement, please contact us in time