The new version of "Armageddon" has been broadcast since the end of June, and now the whole series has come to an end. The main reason why the drama was selected to be broadcast in this time period may be to welcome the founding day of the party on July 1, and to show everyone the grandeur and difficulty of the liberation war.
Under normal circumstances, like this kind of historical war drama with the theme of the three major battles, the shooting of historical war dramas will attract many history and military enthusiasts, and their expectations are also high, after all, it is a historical drama, but also the history of the liberation war period, there must not be too many unrealistic things, contrary to historical facts.
The new version of "Armageddon" looked down on the whole drama, the overall evaluation is not very good, in addition to the role and historical figures are not like, there are many relatively low-level flaws, many historical facts and details are not in place, causing netizens to complain.
The first is the question of the number of troops, in the new version of "Armageddon", the virtual character Takeo Guan spent a lot of time describing. In the play, it is explained that Wu Xiongguan's unit is called 8 companies of 1 battalion, 2nd regiment of the 3rd Division of Shandong, which seems to have no problem, but actually made a basic common sense mistake.
Those who like the military probably know that according to the convention, the troops use a three-three formation. That is, a regular infantry regiment should have three infantry battalions and nine infantry companies. Of the three battalions, the first battalion had three companies, 1, 2 and 3, the second battalion had three companies of 4, 5 and 6, and so on.
Wuxiongguan's unit number is Shandong 3rd Division 2 Regiment 1 Battalion 8th Company, since it is a virtual figure, according to normal logic, should be The unit to which Wuxiongguan belongs should be regularly organized, there is no problem with the 1st Battalion of the 2nd Regiment of the 3rd Division, that is, this 8th Battalion is obviously a bit out of line with the conventional establishment, a battalion should be under the jurisdiction of 1, 2, 3 companies, even if it is a reinforced battalion, a battalion will not have 7 companies, if this is the case, the number of that battalion can not be a regiment.
On the issue of details, Du Yuming's title of Chen Cheng is also a big failure. As we all know, the factional struggle within the Kuomintang is very fierce, and the instructors in the former Whampoa Military Academy have already divided into several factions. The "civil engineering department" headed by Chen Cheng was deeply trusted by Chiang Kai-shek, and He Yingqin, the number two figure in the Kuomintang, also had his own faction, and although there was no contradiction with Chiang Kai-shek on the surface, he was secretly competing.
In terms of relationships, Chen Cheng should be Du Yuming's teacher, although Du Yuming graduated from the First Phase of Huangpu, Chen Cheng did not join as a student when the Whampoa Military Academy was established, but through the introduction of Deng Yanda, he came to the Whampoa Military Academy as an instructor. Even if Chen Cheng had not taught Du Yuming, on the relationship, the two were in a teacher-student relationship at the Whampoa Military Academy, and Du Yuming was unlikely to call Chen Cheng "rhetoric." ”
Moreover, within the Huangpu department, He Yingqin and Chen Cheng were at odds, and Du Yuming himself was on the he Yingqin faction, and the two were relatively close. Du Yuming's image is honest and moderate, and the KmT is very particular about seniority, And Du Yuming will not be so ignorant of the "rules" to call Chen Cheng a rhetoric. In addition to Chiang Kai-shek, there were also those first- and second-class generals such as Li Zongren, Bai Chongxi and others, and others did not dare to call Chen Cheng's name directly.
In addition to the details of the new version of "Armageddon", there are many problems in the restoration of historical events and characters. For example, when Dongye was fighting jinzhou, Zhu Rui, a senior commander of the People's Liberation Army and commander of artillery, unfortunately died, and he was also the highest-ranking general of our army during the entire liberation war.
Zhu Rui's misfortune caused our army to sacrifice an excellent senior general, and all the members of the Northeast Field Army were very sad. In the new version of "Armageddon", when the senior generals of the Nationalist army learned of Zhu Rui's sacrifice, they were celebrating their collective merits, which happened when old Jiang was meeting.
When Old Jiang learned of Zhu Rui's sacrifice and his subordinates all held up wine glasses to celebrate the merits, he not only did not "celebrate" with the soldiers, but also used this matter to educate his subordinates. What is even more incredible is that because his generals celebrated the death of Zhu Rui, Chiang Kai-shek even announced that the meeting was temporarily cancelled, and this "divine horse" fragment is believed that many people have not understood, and the old Chiang kai-shek will do this for Zhu Rui?
From a neutral point of view, it is not wrong to say that the senior generals of our army have been killed and the enemy is happy to celebrate. However, chiang kai-shek learned that after Zhu Rui's death, he taught his subordinates a lesson, and this wave of operations is really difficult for people to understand, and even because of this matter, important meetings were canceled.
What is difficult to understand is that Chiang Kai-shek also wants his subordinates to pay tribute to Zhu Rui, as if the love general around him will die on the battlefield, and regard the enemy general as a model, which is obviously illogical. We all know that both the director and the screenwriter will reflect the tallness of our generals through the actions of the opposing camp, which is an artistic expression that can also be understood. It's just that Chiang Kai-shek paid tribute to Zhu Rui, lost his temper with his subordinates, canceled the meeting, and a series of other moves, which are really a bit "excessive." ”
epilogue
In terms of details and historical facts, in addition to the above, there are many obvious errors. For example, the historical image of Wei Lihuang and Fan Hanjie will not be as "stupid" as in the new version of "Armageddon", a senior general of the Huangpu Phase I, a general of the National Army, and the overall image of the two should be better.
The new version of "Armageddon" may be too rushed to shoot and not grasp the details well, which is also understandable. As a war drama, but also with the three major battles of the Liberation War as the theme, it should be based on the situation of striving for truth, and then carry out artistic creation, and the art of cheating not only has no positive effect, but also may be counterproductive.