On May 22, 2015, a tragedy that shocked society occurred in Hong Kong: a professor's wife and daughter died in a car accident, and behind it all lies a complex and heart-wrenching story. Hui Jinshan, an associate professor of anaesthesiology at the University of Chinese in Hong Kong, has become the focus of police investigations following the death of his wife, Wong Sau-fan, and daughter, Hui Liling. What exactly led to this tragedy? This case not only involves the breakdown of the family, but also reveals the dark side of human nature.
The event passed
Xu Jinshan received a call from the police informing him that his wife and daughter had been poisoned by carbon monoxide and had been unable to be rescued. As an associate professor of medicine, Xu Jinshan's reaction was shock and collapse. When he arrived at the hospital, he was devastated to see the remains of his wife and daughter. As the police investigation deepened, the truth of the case gradually emerged. During the investigation, the police found that there was no external source of leakage in the deceased's car, and the deceased had a gentle personality and had no enemies, which made the case confusing.
After further investigation, the police found that the two yoga balls in the car became the key to the case. What is shocking is that these two yoga balls contain high concentrations of carbon monoxide inside. This gas is colorless and odorless, and can suffocate people unconsciously. The police began to suspect that Xu Jinshan may have deliberately injected carbon monoxide into the yoga ball and placed it in the car to create this "accidental" scene.
Xu Jinshan's motives
Mr. Hui's marital relationship with his wife, Wong Sau Fen, was not harmonious, and his emotional entanglement with a young student, Wing Lee, became more apparent as time went on. Lee's youth and energy attracted Xu Jinshan, and he also used his position to facilitate her studies. As the relationship with Li Yongyi gradually warmed up, Xu Jinshan's feelings for Huang Xiufen gradually faded and even began to consider divorce.
Huang Xiufen filed for divorce after learning of her husband's cheating, which made Xu Jinshan panic. He is well aware that once divorced, he will not only have to divide half of his property, but also face serious damage to his reputation. In this case, Xu Jinshan chose extreme means, trying to get rid of the shackles of this marriage through murder, and he did not expect that his daughter Xu Liling, who was with his wife, was also in the car, which eventually led to a double tragedy.
Police investigation and trial
The investigation of the case did not go well, and the police did not find direct evidence to charge Xu Jinshan at the beginning. It wasn't until 2018 that after a long investigation, the police finally focused on Xu Jinshan. During the court proceedings, Xu Jinshan's behavior raised questions from the judge, especially his act of injecting carbon monoxide into a yoga ball in the laboratory, which became a key piece of evidence in the case.
Xu Jinshan was sentenced to life in prison on two counts of murder. He did not stop there, but chose to appeal. In 2023, the Hong Kong Court of Final Appeal accepted his application for appeal, and the case once again aroused widespread concern in the society. There was a great deal of interest in Xu Jinshan's motives, the complexity of the case, and the police investigation process.
Social repercussions and legal discussions
This case is not only a test of the law, but also a profound reflection on the family and society. Mr. Xu's actions have sparked widespread public debate about domestic violence and emotional entanglements. Many experts point out that this case reflects the fragility of family relationships in contemporary society and the extreme measures that individuals can take in the face of emotional crises.
At the legal level, the trial process of the case has led to a discussion of the standard of evidence. During the trial, the judge pointed out that Xu Jinshan's actions were self-provocative, and he believed that he could not be surprised by the accusations. This view has sparked a heated debate in the legal community, with many legal experts arguing that the complexity of the case and the emotional factors involved make the trial process challenging.
Xu Jinshan's case is a microcosm of tragedy, revealing the complexity and fragility of human nature. Whether as a professor or as a father, Xu Jinshan ultimately chose extreme ways to solve the problem, which led to the breakdown of his family and the loss of his life. As the case is reopened, social attention to the incident continues, and many hope that this case will lead to deeper reflections on family relationships and emotional issues.
How to avoid similar tragedies will be a challenge that all sectors of society need to face together. Whether it is the improvement of the law or the importance attached to family relations, it is an important measure to prevent the recurrence of tragedies. It is hoped that this incident can serve as a warning to make more people realize that communication and understanding are the best way to solve problems.