What would have been the outcome of the Battle of Changping if Zhao Kuo's suggestion had been directly adopted at the beginning?

Some people said that if King Xiaocheng of Zhao had listened to Yu Qing's words, Zhao Guo would at least have been able to get help from other countries. However, King Xiaocheng of Zhao, instead of listening, directly sent people to the State of Qin to make peace, so that other countries did not help the State of Zhao.

Specific to a certain battlefield, the command ability of generals, the ability of the army to execute, and the quality of individual soldiers are indeed decisive factors in the outcome of a war.

In fact, in the dispute between the two countries, the test is naturally comprehensive strength, of course, the most obvious embodiment of this comprehensive strength is still military strength (that is, the above-mentioned general command ability, army execution ability, individual quality). Li Mu defeated the Qin army many times but the territorial deficit of the Zhao state gradually decreased, and Xiang Yu defeated the Han army many times but was gradually retreating, indicating that the victory or defeat of a certain battle could not completely determine the fate of the two countries.

Before the Battle of Changping began, Qin and Zhao actually did not expect to hold each other for three years, and at the beginning they were all about 200,000 troops, and they all thought that they would not use the strength of the whole country to start. Now we stand in God's point of view, if at the beginning Lian Po did not take advantage of the absolute superiority in troop strength and Qin Junye victory was still quite large, but unfortunately Lian Po was not as strong as Zhao Kuo, and after a failure with the Qin army, he withdrew from the first tower and withdrew to the danshui River east to defend the second tower, and then the Qin army pushed the second tower several times and could not push it on the danshui River west to camp with Lian Po, Lian Po thought that the Qin army could not attack and consume a period of time and then withdrew on its own, but Lian Po did not expect that the Qin army and even the entire Qin state had begun to use up the strength of the country and Zhao Guo. At this time, Zhao Guo was already doomed to fail, Zhao Guo could not afford to spend, just like two tigers fighting was originally five or five, no one dared to move first, the two looked at each other with their teeth, they were hungry for three days and three nights, who turned around and ran first and faced being eaten by another, but a tiger was bigger than the other, and the small one couldn't help but go out and do it first and the result was killed by the bigger tiger.

Moreover, the two countries have been facing each other for three years, and the spies between each other must have infiltrated a lot, once there is a combat policy opposite, it is almost known, and it will not give you the opportunity to raid, if the Qin army can't afford to attack first, then the Qin army can't attack the barrier is also going to fail miserably, but the Qin state is strong and can barely be consumed, that is, to wait for Zhao Guo to move first, so Zhao Kuo's coming to the battlefield at this time is basically to destroy the regiment, and here we must not think about why Zhao Kuo wants the whole army to attack. If half of the troops attack half of the defensive barriers, it seems that the consequences will still be defeated, half of the attack is not to say whether it can defeat the Qin army in the case of less than the Qin army's strength, even if the Zhao army that pulls out the qin army's barrier and the Zhao army that guards the barrier in the rear is separated from the Danshui River, it will still be surrounded by the Qin army around the bank of the Danshui River and is surrounded by nearly twice as many troops as it is, even if the Zhao army guarding the barrier all come to relieve the Qin army to defend the river and the Zhao army in the battle barrier can not come to the rescue, it is not to wash Zhao Kuo, Zhao Kuo just couldn't do it before the whole army attacked and fought to the death or could win.