#头条创作挑战赛##理想家生活##长文创作激励计划#
Recently, Han Xue was scolded on the hot search again, which was originally just a complaint from netizens, but after Han Xue officially posted "Reply", "It completely angered netizens."
Netizens said that we don't carry this pot!
Han Xue was scolded again?
Recently, Han Xue performed a song "Growing Up with a Weight of 10,000 Pounds" on the stage of the popular variety show "Riding the Wind 2024".
It's still live.
Next door "Singer 2024" can even be sung in the live broadcast by the diva, which shows its difficulty. And she gave up the classic singing method, chose one person to play two roles, and interpreted a song with four voices, but was complained by the whole network that it was "ugly".
First of all, it was originally a children's part, and Han Xue chose to perform it herself, but soon netizens found out that this was not Han Xue's style of drama that had just been ridiculed by the whole network? followed by a super sticky clip bubble sound and embarrassing crying, which made netizens call it too greasy.
Han Xue, who has endured it for so long, finally broke out, and publicly stated that the aesthetic freedom of music is respectful to every netizen's sense of hearing and viewing. But in this song, refuse to play memes. I hope that everyone will respect the author and the work.
The song "Growing Up with a Weight of 10,000 Pounds" was inspired by the movie "Su Yuan", and the author wanted to convey the great pain suffered by the victim's body and mind, hoping that this song would not become the material for ridicule and memes.
This response undoubtedly stepped on the minefield of netizens and completely angered everyone.
commented in response to his obvious complaining about Han Xue's interpretation, expressing the discomfort of hearing and perception, not respecting the work itself and the story behind it, Han Xue is secretly changing the concept.
So the question is, is the interpretation of this song professional, or is it simply ugly?
Is it professional, or is it "ugly"?
It's not the first time Han Xue has been complained about, Ding Taisheng once commented on Han Xue, her singing skills are okay among those who act, and her acting skills are okay among those who sing, she is just an ordinary person, but she always wants to behave unusually.
Her expressiveness seems to have been written on her face, and she has released 7 albums as a singer; As an actor, he showed his attitude with "not filming kiss scenes", and participated in acting competitions to show his acting skills; I wanted to transform into a director, so I made a movie; It is also very active in major variety shows.
Among the many performances, the dubbing of "Stepmother's Tea Party" is the most outstanding, which also brings Han Xue a lot of confidence, and perhaps it is also this confidence in her vocal skills that makes her choose to use 4 kinds of voices to interpret this song.
But this song is not suitable for showmanship, in addition to the function of transmitting and expressing emotions in musical attributes, it also has the role of spreading social responsibility.
We all know that the movie "Su Yuan" is based on real events, and the story behind it makes countless people feel heartache, so "Growing Up with a Weight of 10,000 Pounds", as a popular song with great dissemination, was created by Taiyi to call on the society to pay attention to sexual assault.
The interpretation of this song is particularly important in the balance between socialization and entertainment, and Han Xue's sometimes smiling singing state is also an important reason why netizens are dissatisfied.
This makes one wonder if she really understands the emotions that the work is trying to express.
Maybe you're not professional in music, but the feelings themselves don't lie.
Han Xue's post this time also made netizens start to think, since singers can freely choose the way they approve of singing songs, why can't the audience freely express their feelings and freely evaluate whether a song is good or bad?
Is there a right to say "ugly"?
Since this song is displayed on a variety show platform, it is for the public to enjoy.
The music delivered on the public platform needs most people to listen to comfortably, even if the music aesthetic is free, there is a high probability that there is no extreme inconsistency between the aesthetics of the author, the interpreter, and the audience.
This is similar to the movie, maybe you don't know that the shooting and interpretation of this movie are professional, but everyone knows whether the movie is good-looking, as long as it is a good movie, even if there is no big publicity, it will explode in an instant.
It's the same with musical works, maybe not everyone understands music, but everyone has the right to express their feelings.
So some netizens paid attention to Han Xue's explanation of "music aesthetic freedom", since it is free, then our aesthetics is that we think this song is ugly.
is still the same point of view, the aesthetic level is high and low, but it is not good or bad.
Some people are naturally sensitive, whether it is music, color, emotional experience, etc., it is easy to capture and feel.
People who are not talented can also learn theoretical knowledge through deliberate practice, and get in touch with various arts to immerse themselves in it, which can also slowly improve their aesthetic level.
But there is no such thing as good or bad aesthetics, but different beauties from different perspectives.
Then why is there always such a voice in life, "Why are you so low", "This work is so ugly"...... For example, this time, someone directly gave a "ugly" evaluation of Han Xue's singing?
One of the most important is the confusion between factual and value judgments.
Unlike visual arts, music is an auditory art, which cannot be seen or touched, so the aesthetic experience of music depends more on human mental activity.
Some researchers have found that the aesthetic experience of music involves the processing of perception, cognition and emotion, and people will reflect their own music aesthetics through three parts: emotion, judgment and preference.
Take Han Xue's work, using drama to sing and interpret children's voices, which is too different from everyone's past experience of children's voices, and then added bubble sounds that everyone feels that they are labeled greasy, and it is easy to "play".
For an ordinary audience, the whole experience is a dissonance and discomfort of perception, cognition, and emotion, and naturally there is an "ugly" evaluation. Ke Yimin's dazzling singing style also made netizens find it difficult to accept.
All in all, everyone has their own musical aesthetics, and aesthetic freedom is understandable, but it also has its own boundaries, that is, the "harmony" of perception and emotions, and a good music experience is more important to ordinary people than exquisite skills.
(Excerpted from WeChat public account Yinke Aesthetics)